The Right Direction, a.k.a. One White Dude’s Confession

About a week before we moved into our new house, some guy broke into a home about four blocks away and killed an entire family. I saw the headlines while, um, researching something online at work, then texted the Manly Fireplug.

“Five dead. But the paper says it took place in Sunnyside!” That would be the next neighborhood over from ours, and it was my attempt to inject lame humor into the mid-level anxiety we had about the location of our new home.

But a few days later I checked again, and now Wikipedia, our greatest repository of fact, called it “2012 Ingleside, San Francisco homicide.”  We consoled ourselves with the rumor that the killer already knew his victims, because frankly, it was too late for us to turn back.

I also consoled myself with other “facts.” The victims were Chinese. The suspect Vietnamese.

This post is taking me a long time to write, in part because it’s about my own racism, and I want to be rigorously honest.  I’d rather not do such a thing, so I keep clicking away to read about Cabin in the Woods and to shop for new shower caddies. And it’s taking me a long time to write because we’ve lived in the house all of 12 days, and my thoughts and feelings about my new neighborhood are muddled.

But hey, half-baked conclusions are what blogs are for, so away we go…

Ingleside is one of San Francisco’s more obscure neighborhoods. “You know, near City College,” I tell literally everyone when they give me that blank, where-did-you-move look. Located on the city’s southern edge, Ingleside has no distinguishing landmarks, and offers few results when typed into Google. It’s also one of the last affordable neighborhoods left in the city. If by “affordable” you mean single-family homes that sell for a half-million dollars.

One night, the week before we moved in, the Fireplug and I stopped by the house. We’d done this a few times, walking through the empty rooms and picturing our future. I think it’s what people do when they buy a house. I’d always drag the Fireplug into the backyard, which was surprisingly peaceful and offered a glimpse of the bay and the Oakland hills.

On this particular night, standing in the living room, we noticed a black couple coming out of the house two doors down. The woman turned to yell something to a man in their garage, then climbed into a car and drove off. The man in the garage turned on some very loud music, and left the garage door open for the next hour. The Fireplug and I looked at each other.

“You know our to-do list?” I said. “Let’s move double-pane windows to the top.”

Just now I could have called our neighbors African-American instead of black. I’m a writer; I understand the power of words. And there’s an unrelenting pressure to be politically correct, living in San Francisco, which black people are leaving in droves. At least I think that’s still the politically correct term. I’d ask my black friends what they preferred, but I don’t have that many. Which may be part of my problem.

I’m a researcher by nature, which I’ve realized from writing a 350-page memoir is probably due to a rather chaotic childhood and a deep aversion to surprise. I like to know what’s coming my way. Especially when I’ve just committed to buying my first house.

And so I went online and looked up census figures for the quarter-mile surrounding our new Ingleside house. And I focused my search on race. And that night I presented my findings to the Fireplug.

“Over the last eight years Asians have held steady at 50% of the neighborhood’s population,” I said. “Hispanics have dropped by 8%. American Indians dropped by 37%. Blacks dropped by 30%. Whites have increased by 23%. Oh, and people with graduate degrees grew by 110%.”

I want to be clear here. I wasn’t just reciting facts. I was offering proof that the neighborhood was heading in the right direction.

By “right” I meant “safer.” I’m not saying this was a rational act. I used percentages of racial minorities to try and ease my anxiety.

I like to think of myself as an open-minded guy, able to look past skin color to the individual blah blah blah. Nobody’s asked my position on the Trayvon Martin/George Zimmerman mess, but it’s hard not to have one in our echo chamber. I’d say that public rushes to judgment are usually ill-advised. Off the record I was leaning in my usual liberal direction.

It’s easy to think of yourself as open-minded about race when you spend 95% of your time in neighborhoods that are 95% white. But moving into what real estate agents call a “diverse” neighborhood had ripped open my broad-minded disguise to reveal something else underneath.

The day we moved in, the Fireplug stood out on the sidewalk, directing the movers to carry stuff either upstairs or downstairs, and I stood inside, directing them to the right rooms. The Fireplug and I have this running joke about his habit of talking to strangers, a habit (surprise!) I don’t share. After the movers left, the Fireplug told me that more than a few neighbors had stopped by to welcome us.

He already knew their names. Susan, the Asian woman in the bright orange house, who dressed to the nines even when walking her little dog around the block. Brian and Rick, the gay couple across the street, who’d moved into their renovated house with two adopted kids, and who literally cheered when the Fireplug mentioned that he had a husband, too. Carlton, the black man from two doors down, who sat with two other black men on lawn chairs outside the open garage, watching the afternoon drift by.  And Austin, the Chinese man next door, who was thrilled to hear that we owned and not rented, and who told us that yes, the residents of Carlton’s house often listened to loud music, but it never went late, and in fact they acted as the unofficial neighborhood watch. They knew who belonged on our street, and who didn’t.

In other words, the Fireplug discovered things that no census could reveal. And yes, I felt foolish. And relieved. And thankful for the Fireplug’s big mouth.

Today our house is half-rewired and half-unpacked, our windows rattle, the shower’s cramped, and our kitchen won’t be appearing in Elle Decor anytime soon. But the house gets a ton of light, and I like going home to it, to our three dogs and the big backyard. I like waking up with the Fireplug.

And in the evenings, after work, when I take the dogs on our comical, leash-snarling, hill-climbing walk, I try to meet the eye of everyone I pass. Some of them talk to me. Some of them glare. Sometimes I’m glad that one of our dogs is a pit bull. (He’s arguably the sweetest member of our pack, but strangers don’t need to know that.) Every time I step outside I’m conscious, in a way I never was in my last neighborhood, of my skin color.  That’s not a bad thing.

And in 12 days Ingleside has grown on me. Most of the houses are modest. There’s trash in some yards, neglected gardens, cars propped up on blocks, “Beware of Rotweiler” signs, and acres of peeling paint. There’s a house around the corner where a young man was recently killed. It’s boarded up, with a row of candles out front, and outer walls covered in his friends’ testimonials. He was described by reporters as an “aspiring rapper,” and the articles about him, lean on details, ran for a single day. I looked him up on Facebook. He was twenty years old, and his profile says, “Engaged.”

There are “nice” houses, too, probably owned by people who, like me, sometimes pick up a copy of Dwell. But it’s the other houses I like to look at, walking the dogs, or on my way to the BART station every morning. And this is the point at which words fail me, explaining why I like them so much.

Because every possible word (“Real?” “Honest?”) sounds patronizing, the words liberal urban white guys use to romanticize the fading parts of their neighborhoods. After paging through several dozen Dwell photo spreads, after the ubiquitous bowl of green “apples” and countless Keep Calm posters, I yearn to see something a little more alive. Ingleside – whose residents show evidence of caring about things other than minimalist design- feels quietly alive.

Last weekend the Fireplug’s sister came to town and helped us do some unpacking and painting. After our second trip to Home Depot, we came home with a weed wacker, which the Fireplug used on our entire, quarter-acre backyard of 18″ grass/weeds. He also wacked the weeds out front, and Carlton, who was entertaining a few friends with a barbeque outside his garage, ran down to say that he had saved a parking spot for us on the street. He could just move his car and it was ours, he said. His barbeque was loud, but it didn’t go late. None of his parties had gone late.

More than once, before our move, I’d found myself defending our new neighborhood in a half-joking manner, pointing out new development on Ocean Avenue. “Because what’s a better sign of gentrification than Whole Foods? Ha ha ha.”

But as the 12 days ticked by, my little census research left me feeling gross and increasingly uncomfortable.

It’s humbling to see myself as a cliche. A gay white man moving into a “fringe” neighborhood, fixing up his home, paving the way for others like him. I am part of the 23% surge in white people. Which, it stands to reason, means that I’m changing Ingleside.

If there’s justice in the world, though, Ingleside will change me, too.

Posted April 19th, 2012 in fireplug, gay marriage, ingleside, story.

14 comments:

  1. Matt Fuller, GRI:

    Wow. I always enjoy your writing, but this post more so since I know some of the back story and spend all day talking about and spending time in SF neighborhoods. An incredibly honest reflection – stop unpacking and finish your book!!!!

  2. dogpoet:

    Thanks Matt :) My next post will address that whole book thing. In a good way.

  3. Tim:

    Man, your writing just keeps getting better and better. I love reading about your adventures in real estate and new home. It’s cool that I can identify with your stories about you and the manly fireplug even though my own husband and I live all the way across the country in beautiful Memphis, Tennessee. Thank you for the gift of your writing. It puts a little light in a dark place.

  4. Michael Ritz:

    I agree your writing gets better and better. It brought back memories of a home that I lived in Colorado called 5 points. Our home had two very active black baptist churches at each end of the block. I would get up early on the week-ends just to see the women in there Sunday best. Congrats on the new home and enjoy the new neighborhood. Like Fireplug… I talk to everyone. I can’t help it. My friends all know this about me.

  5. dogpoet:

    Thank you Tim.

    And thanks Michael. As I hope is clear from this story, the Fireplug’s way with strangers makes him the hero. Without him I would know very few people, including our neighbors.

  6. Daigan:

    Thank you for your honesty. This is actually the way to overcome racism more than anything else. Folks standing up and telling the truth about their working it out. It not easy and it’s not popular, but thank you for doing it.

  7. Paul:

    Nice, Baby.

    xoxox

  8. Buck:

    I appreciate your honesty in this post.

    It’s great that you have your husband to be friendly with the neighbours. Hopefully you can make some good connexions and live in true community. One thing about gentrification is that some qualities that make a neighbourhood appealing (being “alive” as you say) are what go away as the mostly-white middle class takes over.

    The documentary Flag Wars might be of interest to you. Already you are developing a less antagonistic relationship that those shown in the movie, but I think it’s still worth seeing.

  9. John:

    handsome, talented, and honest. good on you, michael. keep it up. looking forward to reading lots more.

  10. Fred Katz:

    Damm you write gud!

  11. Jeffrey C:

    Great closing lines to a wonderful post.

    I would encourage you to check your bias about minimal design though. If that’s the way some people live, it’s very alive to them, even if it may not appear do to other.

    One of my peeves is when people on design blogs comment that they want homes more alive or lived-in as if there is a more omnipotent standard associated with those terms. The diversity of what is alive or lived-in is as great as the diversity of the people doing the living.

  12. dogpoet:

    I actually love minimalist design. So much that I read lots of blogs and magazines. The only annoying part, for me, is when you see some of the same choices crop up over and over. Like the bowl of green apples and the Keep Calm posters, which are so ubiquitous that they end up telling you nothing about who lives there. It starts to feel deadening, if that makes sense.

    “Minimalist” is actually not the right word. That’s the problem with blogging. Sometimes you grab the wrong word without giving it enough thought.

  13. cminca:

    Michael,

    You may want to investigate the concept of Wabi-Sabi (yes, there is a wikipedia entry). It may be more appropriate, comfortable, and “real” to you than Minimalisms striving for “perfection”. Certainly Wabi-sabi will be easier for a household that includes three dogs.

    Also–check out “World of Interiors”–a British decor magazine. You won’t find the banal line up of over the top decors in some of the usual suspects–Elle Decor, Architectural Digest, etc–but you will find some absolutely great ideas on how people actually live.

    Good luck.

  14. Stuart:

    Thanks for this, Dogpoet. Like you, we recently moved to a similar neighborhood about a mile away from yours, and your adventures have a familiar ring to them — except you tell them much better than we do. We have learned to value both our gaybors and all of our neighbors — we have never lived on a more varied block, and we are loving it.